This is a crosspost of mine from over at Catholic Dads. I posted this last night and a couple of my fellow Catholic Dads as well as some moms for good measure have gotten started discussing the efficacy of nursing past toddlerhood. Not a direction I planned for the post to go, but if you’re interested, please check out the combox!
My lovely and gracious wife alerted me to this, so I decided to throw a post up about it.
For those of you whose kids were born in the hospital, and I know that’s most of us, you probably remember receiving a “free” sample bag from one of the major baby formula companies. Nice bag, equipped to carry bottles, and even came with a couple of free samples of formula.
Now, ignoring the point about Nestle’s repeated patently evil actions in 3rd world countries regarding formula, we all know that this is an economics game. The formula companies give hospitals monetary kickbacks as well as reduced price formula for use in the NICU, in return for the hospitals giving everyone one of these bags. I’m of the opinion (and science supports me) that breastmilk is the far superior food for newborns, and that physical and emotional health of both mom and baby are substantially enhanced by breastfeeding as long as possible (in my case, my 2-year-old continues to nurse, albeit briefly, even as my wife is pregnant with another.) Conversely, physical and mental health of mother and baby are compromised by the use of inferior product - formula - as the primary means of sustenance.
Still, the bags are being handed out, and you have to figure that their availability is influencing new moms, at least to some degree. The response to this is a website called banthebags.org, a new website set up by concerned moms citing evidence that there’s just too much evidence that moms are in fact being influenced by these “free” samples. They’ve even been featured on NPR.
Not to be outdone, there’s now momsfeedingfreedom.com, which advocates for not banning the bags. It was set up in direct response to the banthebags movement. It’s all about how important it is for the bags to be distributed because not distributing them denies new moms adequate information and education about their options. The site pays lip service to the “breast is best” concept, but it ignores all sorts of scientific evidence and you can just tell it’s a pro-formula site. In fact, it’s sponsored by the International Formula Council. And yes, that means it stinks worse than formula spit-up. Out the window goes any appearance of being objective. The cool thing is, there is a blog on the site, and the majority of the comments are pro-breast and anti-formula.
So, Catholic Dads, as we know, breastfeeding is a key part of natural child spacing and therefore NFP…so if any of your wives are militant breastfeeders as my wife is, have them check out the above sites and include their two cents.
Disclaimer: I am a La Leche League Dad - I am unabashed in my support of breastfeeding mothers. I believe breastfeeding is far superior to anything else for babies. That said, I do understand there are rare situations where it just doesn’t work for one reason or other. I do not condemn anyone for their personal decisions. Rather, I condemn the aggressive marketing of the formula industry as well as the cultural mentalities that have made formula feeding so mainstream. Don’t string me up, please!